Published: May 6, 2026 - 10:00 AM
Sindh High Court Expresses Concern Over Delay in Karachi Red Line BRT Project
کراچی ریڈ لائن بی آر ٹی منصوبے میں تاخیر پر سندھ ہائی کورٹ کا اظہارِ تشویش
▫️An entire lifetime cannot be given for the completion of a project, court remarks
Karachi | ReNews Pakistan The Sindh High Court has expressed concern over the delay in the completion of Karachi’s Red Line Bus Rapid Transit project, observing that the slow pace of work continues to cause serious difficulties for ci...
The Sindh High Court has expressed concern over the delay in the completion of Karachi’s Red Line Bus Rapid Transit project, observing that the slow pace of work continues to cause serious difficulties for citizens.
A two member bench comprising Justice Nisar Ahmed Bhanbhro and Justice Saleem Jessar heard a petition filed by the contractor of Red Line BRT Lot Two. The petition raised the issue of the sealing of the contractor’s office and the ongoing dispute between the contractor and relevant authorities over the execution of the project. During the hearing, Justice Nisar Ahmed Bhanbhro remarked that the pace of work from University Road to Safoora did not appear satisfactory, adding that the court was also concerned over the delay in the project. The court observed that side roads should have been constructed immediately after the project began in order to reduce public inconvenience.
The bench further remarked that an entire lifetime cannot be given for the completion of a project. The court questioned how the project could be completed within the stipulated timeframe when the designs themselves were being provided late.
The petitioner’s counsel argued that repeated changes in the project design were a major reason behind the delay. According to the counsel, the design was changed several times on the grounds that the K-IV water supply line would also be laid along the project route.
The lawyer told the court that an impression had been created among the public that the contractor alone was responsible for the delay, whereas citizens were suffering due to the ongoing dispute between the contractor and the government, and the actual reasons behind the delay had not been clearly brought to light.
Justice Saleem Jessar observed that the Red Line BRT is a major infrastructure project and that contracts for such projects are usually awarded after the completion of designs. The court questioned how work could move forward smoothly when the design itself was incomplete.
The petitioner’s counsel also alleged that the matter was being deliberately delayed so that the contract could be awarded to another company. According to the counsel, the relevant authorities had also written to the Asian Development Bank, claiming that the contractor was not performing the work properly.
In response, Justice Saleem Jessar remarked that, prima facie, the authorities appeared to be attempting to absolve themselves of responsibility.
During the hearing, the petitioner’s counsel completed his arguments. The court directed the Advocate General Sindh and the counsel for TransKarachi to present their arguments at the next hearing.