Published: September 16, 2026 - 3:05 PM
New Provinces or Stronger Local Government? Pakistan Must Fix Governance Before Redrawing Its Map
نئے صوبے یا بااختیار بلدیاتی نظام؟ پاکستان کو نیا نقشہ بنانے سے پہلے حکمرانی کا مسئلہ حل کرنا ہوگا
▫️Muhammad Faisal Sulehria
Smaller provinces may improve administrative access, but without meaningful political, financial and administrative devolution, Pakistan risks creating more centres of power rather than bringing government closer to citizensPakistan’s go...
Pakistan’s governance crisis is becoming increasingly difficult to ignore. A country of nearly 250 million people is being administered through structures that often appear too centralised, too distant and too slow to respond to the everyday needs of citizens.
This has revived an important national debate: should Pakistan create new provinces and smaller administrative units to improve governance?
The question deserves serious consideration. But before boundaries are redrawn, another question must be answered. Will new provinces actually decentralise power, or will they simply reproduce the same governance problems within smaller geographical areas?
The argument for smaller provinces has considerable merit. Provinces with populations running into tens of millions can themselves become highly centralised systems. Political authority, financial resources and administrative decision making often remain concentrated in provincial capitals, leaving remote districts with limited influence over decisions that directly affect them.
Smaller administrative units could reduce the distance between citizens and government. They could allow regional priorities to receive greater attention, make public institutions more responsive and provide communities that feel politically neglected with a stronger voice.
South Punjab has long been at the centre of demands for a separate province. Islamabad could also be considered within a wider debate over administrative restructuring, while other proposals may deserve examination on the basis of population, geography, economic viability and administrative efficiency.
But creating a province is far more complicated than drawing new lines on a map.
Any alteration in the federal structure would involve constitutional procedures, political consensus and, where provincial boundaries are affected, approval by the relevant provincial legislature. New provincial governments would require assemblies, cabinets, secretariats, administrative departments and bureaucratic structures.
There would also be significant financial consequences.
Each new province would require a share of national resources. Revenue distribution arrangements would have to be reconsidered, while questions involving assets, liabilities, government employees, public institutions and development responsibilities would need to be resolved.
Before Pakistan moves towards such a major restructuring, policymakers should therefore present credible estimates of the costs involved and measurable evidence of the governance benefits expected from the change.
There is an even more fundamental issue.
If the political and administrative culture remains unchanged, smaller provinces could simply become smaller versions of the existing system. Power may shift from one provincial capital to several new provincial capitals without ever reaching districts, towns and neighbourhoods.
New bureaucracies could reproduce old bureaucratic weaknesses. New political elites could control resources in much the same way as existing ones. Citizens could still remain dependent on distant offices for decisions concerning local services.
This is why the debate over new provinces cannot be separated from the debate over local government.
Pakistan already has a constitutional and administrative mechanism capable of bringing government significantly closer to citizens: empowered local governments.
Municipalities, districts and local councils deal with many of the services that shape daily life, including local roads, sanitation, water supply, land use, municipal regulation, public spaces and community infrastructure. Yet local government remains one of the weakest parts of Pakistan’s democratic structure.
Provincial governments have historically shown limited willingness to transfer meaningful political, administrative and financial authority to elected local institutions.
This creates an obvious contradiction.
Political parties strongly defend provincial autonomy when powers and resources are being transferred from Islamabad to the provinces. Yet the same principle becomes far less attractive when provincial capitals are asked to transfer authority and money to districts, cities and neighbourhoods.
The reason is partly political.
An empowered local government system distributes control over development funds, public services and administrative decisions. It places resources closer to voters and reduces the dependence of communities on provincial legislators and party leadership structures.
Those who currently exercise these powers therefore have little political incentive to surrender them.
This does not mean that Pakistan should reject the idea of new provinces. Demographic growth, regional inequalities and administrative pressures may eventually make additional provinces necessary.
The debate may, in fact, already be overdue.
But any serious proposal must go beyond slogans. It should identify the proposed boundaries, explain the constitutional process, calculate the financial cost, assess the economic viability of each new unit and demonstrate how public services would improve.
Most importantly, any restructuring plan should explain how authority will continue moving downward after a new province is created.
Pakistan may indeed need a different administrative map. But changing the map alone will not repair governance.
The real test of reform is not how many provinces appear on the map. It is how close political authority, public money and decision making ultimately move towards the citizen.
If new provinces merely create additional capitals where power remains concentrated, Pakistan will have reorganised centralisation rather than eliminated it.
A meaningful reform would do something more ambitious: redraw not only administrative boundaries, but also the relationship between the state and the citizen.